Why malfoy elder wand

Rowling has shared that the core of the Elder Wand is the tail hair of a Thestral, "a powerful and tricky substance that can be mastered only by a witch or wizard capable of facing death. Rowling Therefore, Voldemort would never have been able to truly master the Elder Wand, no matter how he came to possess it. Voldemort was incapable of facing death. As we know, Harry faced death twice, once unknowingly as an infant, once deliberately as a teen. Accordingly, Harry was able to both master and win the allegiance of the Elder Wand.

The wand's allegiance changes when its master is "defeated. If you've disarmed a wizard, they're at your mercy, you've essentially defeated them. It doesn't matter whether the wand is present; since it is magical, it will know its master has been defeated, and by whom. In actual fact, Malfoy did disarm Dumbledore, but had no clue that he now possessed the wand.

However since Snape did not actually disarm Dumbledore, the wand wouldn't cooperate with Lord Voldemort. After looking at the Pensieve, Harry realizes that Snape was not to blame for Dumbledore's death and figures out that Draco Malfoy did disarm Dumbledore.

After Harry Potter defeats Lord Voldemort, he actually explains to Hermione and Ron how he had just recently disarmed Malfoy, making Harry owner of the wand. However, seeing as the Elder Wand with its powers has caused so much trouble, wars and deaths alike, he places it back into Dumbledore's grave in the book; in the film he snaps it in two , thinking the wizarding world would be much better without it.

Here is an attempt at a reply to the initial question. I think, and I am not well acquainted with the books, that it is a special feature of the elder wand, a special feature of "power", if you will, that its allegiance is of such a transient nature. However, in my point of view that is not necessarily intrinsic to ordinary wands just as much. However, Voldemort believes that you have to kill a person to get it, making it so the wand goes from Dumbledore to Snape to Voldemort.

Snape killed Dumbledore so the wand was then his. Voldemort killed Snape so the wand was then Voldemort's and Voldemort was killed by Harry but then Harry snapped the wand in two and threw it away. Does this make sense to anyone else but me?! Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top.

Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more. How did Harry come to master the Elder Wand? Ask Question. Asked 9 years, 11 months ago. Active 8 months ago. Viewed k times. Improve this question. Jay Jay 1 1 gold badge 3 3 silver badges 4 4 bronze badges. Add a comment.

Active Oldest Votes. Improve this answer. It is actually a very liberating scene from the novel, so fans are pretty upset when Harry Daniel Radcliffe is shown simply breaking the Elder Wand instead of first repairing his own. The fact that the Elder Wand can even procure this type of magic is very telling about its characteristics.

While stationary objects like glasses can be easily mended by wands, repairing a broken wand with another is not typical feat. In fact, no other wand can do this sort of magic. A Thestral, for those who have forgotten, is the skeleton-like horse with wings.

They are invisible to everyone, save for those who have witnessed death. Each wand has some sort of feather from a magical creature Harry' wand has a Phoenix feather, for example. The Elder Wand contains a Thestral tail-hair core, which is a very rare marrow.

According to J. Rowling, this core is, "a tricky substance that only wizards that mastered death can control. The "Elder" feature in its name is derived from two separate sources. The first is that the wand itself is made out of wood from an elder tree.

As you can see, the Elder Wand captures a unique presence, one with circular-like fixtures embedded into its length fifteen inches, by the way. Those are the resemblance of elderberries, an actual fruit that has some folklore heritage. These legends say that elderberries had been used to protect witches and wizards and to ward off evil. The Elder Wand has been given a few nicknames throughout its existence, most notably spoken by Lord Voldemort.

It has been called the "unbeatable wand" owing to the fact that its sole purpose is to give the owner more power than any other witch or wizard. Voldemort himself speaks of it in high regard, as this is truly the only Deathly Hallows he wished to possess. After Antioch bested another wizard in a duel with the Elder Wand, he boasted about its powers. This foolishly led to him being murdered in his sleep. Ever since then, it has been known that the Elder Wand can be given a new master by whoever can win it over its previous owner.

Some consider it unbeatable, some merely the most potent means of channeling magic in existence, but either way, it has blazed a long and bloody trail through wizarding history. The possessor of all three Hallows—the wand, the Resurrection Stone, and the Cloak of Invisibility—is said to master death. The seventh book showed why that question mattered.

Between that initial theft and the early 20th century, when Beasts takes place, the wand traced a more staccato path, with quieter periods punctuated by loud bursts. There are gaps, of course, and long ones, where it vanishes from view, temporarily lost or hidden; but always it resurfaces. The wizards who sought and then possessed the wand for a time were the kinds of wizards one would expect to desire an all-powerful wand, with names like Emeric the Evil and Egbert the Egregious and Barnabas Deverill.

Like George R. Martin, Rowling has a way with fantastic fictional names. But this relationship goes much further than a mere initial connection. Broadly speaking, any wand is ripe for the taking in a duel. Much also depends upon the wand itself. In general, however, where a wand has been won, its allegiance will change. Yet while some thinking, feeling, quasi-sentient wands weigh different factors when determining their master, the Elder Wand knows what it wants.

It will only go where the power is. Its history is bloody, but that may be simply due to the fact that it is such a desirable object, and arouses such passions in wizards.

This failure to understand culminated in his downfall in the Great Hall, killed by his own backfiring curse as he tried to use the Elder Wand to smite its true master. Does one of them thus become master of the Elder Wand? If so, which one? Here, as Dumbledore says in Half-Blood Prince , we leave the firm foundation of fact and journey instead into thickets of wildest guesswork. About the latter, she said:.

I have been asked a lot of times, well what about Duelling Club and so on? So I think the wand would behave differently then.